{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, the average home in the U.S. consistently sold for more than its previous year's price each month. However, that trend has finally ended. According to October's national statistics, the median home sale price has dipped slightly below last year's figures, marking the first annual decrease since spring 2023. Concurrently, the availability of homes for sale has surged to its highest point since early 2020, pending sales have fallen to their lowest figures in over ten years outside of the early pandemic, and nearly twenty percent of listings have seen price reductions.

However, there is a downside: borrowing costs have risen again. The average 30-year fixed mortgage rate has climbed back into the mid-7% range in the last week, following a brief period of improvements. Although buyers are gaining some power, the monthly payments can still be challenging for many households.

This unique scenario presents a distinct opportunity. Sellers are encountering fewer offers and longer market durations, meaning that the list price and terms are becoming more negotiable. If you're in the market for a home this winter, here's what you might be able to negotiate and how you should approach it with your agent and lender.

Understanding What a Small Price Decline Means

A national decrease of less than half a percent doesn't indicate a market crash and does not imply that prices are dropping everywhere. Certain expensive coastal markets with minimal inventory continue to experience gains, while several major metropolitan areas in the South and West have seen prices decrease several percent from last year. Ultimately, what happens in your local market is far more important than national averages.

The national data highlights a shift in dynamics. With homes remaining on the market longer and more listings competing for a reduced number of buyers, sellers are becoming more open to negotiations. This flexibility can manifest in the sale price as well as the terms of the deal.

Price Is Just One Aspect of the Negotiation

Many buyers tend to concentrate solely on the purchase price, but in a high-interest rate environment, factors such as monthly payment and the amount of cash needed at closing can be even more critical. A few thousand dollars knocked off the price may only slightly reduce your loan. Utilizing that same amount differently could have a more significant impact on your budget. Common negotiation points in a slower market include:

  • A purchase price below the listed figure
  • Seller contributions toward closing costs
  • Repairs completed before closing, or a credit instead of repairs
  • Seller-funded assistance to lower your mortgage rate
  • A closing date or moving schedule that aligns with your needs
  • Included items such as appliances or window coverings

Your real estate agent is knowledgeable about how local sellers are reacting and can assist you in determining which points to prioritize in your offer. The aim should be to focus on the requests that have the most significant impact on your situation.

Using Closing Cost Credits to Alleviate Financial Strain

Typically, closing costs add a few percent to your loan amount, in addition to your down payment. For many first-time buyers, finding this cash is often the most challenging aspect of purchasing a home. A seller's credit can cover some of these expenses directly, allowing you to bring less to the closing table.

It's essential to note there are limits. Different loan programs will restrict how much a seller can contribute, usually between 3% and 9% of the purchase price, depending on the type of loan and the down payment size. Additionally, a credit cannot typically exceed your actual closing costs. Inquire with your lender early on regarding what your specific loan allows to ensure that your requests in the offer meet the established guidelines.

Understanding Rate Buydowns

With interest rates surpassing 7% once again, one of the most valuable offers a seller can make is assistance with your interest rate. There are generally two main types.

A permanent buydown involves paying discount points at closing to reduce your interest rate for the duration of the loan. Each point costs 1% of the loan amount, and the specific rate reduction it provides can vary based on the lender and current market conditions. If you plan to hold on to the loan for an extended period, a permanent buydown can be beneficial.

A temporary buydown, on the other hand, reduces your payments for the first few years. In a common approach, the interest rate might be two percentage points lower in the initial year, one point lower in the second year, and return to the full rate thereafter. For instance, with a $350,000 30-year mortgage at roughly 7.34%, the monthly payment for principal and interest would be about $2,409. Under a temporary buydown scenario, the first year's payment would reduce to around $1,952, followed by about $2,176 in the second year, before reverting to the original payment in the third year. The cost of this structure in the example could exceed $8,000, an amount a seller may opt to provide instead of raising the price by a similar figure.

It's important to understand that a temporary buydown is not a lasting solution. You still need to be comfortable with the total payment once the discount period ends, and lenders typically assess your qualifications based on the full payment. If interest rates decrease in the future, refinancing could be a possibility, but there are no guarantees regarding timing or whether that will happen at all.

Don't Forego the Inspection to Appear Competitive

In a frenzied market, many buyers chose to waive inspections or constrain their requests to gain an edge. However, in a slower market, there's less incentive to sacrifice these essential protections. A comprehensive home inspection can reveal vital information about the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical systems, and foundation before making a commitment.

If an inspection identifies issues, your agent can guide you on whether to request repairs, a price adjustment, or a credit. Opting for credits can be more straightforward than asking the seller to manage repairs since you maintain control over the resolution and how it is performed. However, the right course of action varies depending on the nature of the problem and your loan's requirements.

Prepare Your Financing Ahead of Time

Having negotiating leverage won't be effective if your financing is not secure. A seller reviewing multiple offers is likely to favor the buyer who is most likely to complete the sale. Before you start seriously looking, aim for full preapproval rather than a simple prequalification, be clear on your maximum comfortable monthly payment instead of just your maximum loan limit, and compare estimates from several lenders. Additionally, inquire about how each lender would process a seller credit or buydown to avoid any unexpected issues later on.

Key Questions to Discuss with Your Agent

  • What is the average time homes in this area spend on the market, and how often do we see price reductions?
  • Would a price decrease, closing cost credit, or rate buydown be the most beneficial for my finances?
  • How do the unique characteristics and history of this specific home influence my potential requests?
  • What contingencies should I incorporate into my offer to safeguard my interests?

Summing Up

A market that is softening does not equate to inexpensive home purchasing, particularly with the rise in mortgage rates. However, it opens opportunities for well-prepared buyers to negotiate terms that align better with their financial situations. With comprehensive financial readiness, a solid understanding of your priorities, and the support of your agent and lender, it may be possible to negotiate terms that were previously unimaginable a year or two ago.

Rewritten using AI